Season 12, Season 12 finals

Ranking the Top 4 (again) on American Idol

3 284

This week, American Idol contestants will be yanked into the 21st Century. Finally.

Idol’s theme for Top 4, Part 2 will be “Then and Now.”

Meaning each of the Top 4 will get to sing one of those classic tunes they seem to love so much.

But they’ll also have to sing a hit from 2013. Oh, what will they do?

On with this week’s rankings, which are going to look very similar to last week’s.

I am, however, much more confident in the placement after what we witnessed on Top 4, Week 1.

As always, last week’s rankings are in parenthesis.

Angie Miller of American Idol (FOX Photo)1. Angie Miller (1): I don’t know if she snatched any wigs last week, to borrow a Nicki Minaj illusion, but Angie was the only Idol contestant who showed up on stage with a fierce I-will-be-in-the-Top-3 attitude. Her cover of Jessie J’s “Who You Are” was one of Season 12’s best. On a show where everyone left sings well, a flair for performance counts. And on that count, Angie wins. Hands down.


Candice Glover. of American Idol. (FOX Photo)2. Candice Glover (2): Gasp. The best singer on Idol landed in the bottom two last week. Let’s see if that outcome ignites a fire in Candice that a similar finish failed to ignite in Kree just a week ago. Candice would be well advised to heed the advice of Jimmy Iovine: safe song choices are not going to get her the Season 12 crown. She’ll need more performances along the lines of her take on Paula Abdul’s “Straight Up.”


Kree Harrison (FOX Photo))3. Kree Harrison (3): A high percentrage of what was coming from the judges’ panel last week was garbage. But Keith Urban’s critiques of Kree were dead on. He said she keeps picking “middle-ground” songs that show neither raw emotion nor the fire you’d expect from someone vying for the Idol crown. Always great vocally, Kree need to kick up her performance level … oh, about 100 notches.

Insert art of Grand Canyon here for same reason as last week. There’s a huge gap between the top three and …

Amber Holcomb of American Idol. (FOX Photo)4. Amber Holcomb (4): I keep hearing that Amber might be the most commercially viable contestant. Let’s see. She sings ballads well. Candice and Kree sing them better. Amber has gone upbeat three times. She’s fallen flat three times. You’d expect the most viable contestant to have a burgeoning fan base. Angie picked up more Facebook fans in the past week than Amber has all season. If there’s any justice, this week will end Amber’s Idol viability.

Related Posts


  1. Bubba May 1, 2013 at 5:52 pm -  Reply

    For whatever reason the judges have been trying to pry Amber into the top spot with their phoney standing ovations when she does a mediocred performance, they hoop it up like she’s the queen. Fortunately the voting audience sees thru this mirage and votes for the best of the best, Angie and Kree.

  2. Charlia May 1, 2013 at 8:11 pm -  Reply

    Amber sings the ballads the best and she’s never “fell flat”. You’re just completely bias and most American Idol fans have poor taste. The best one always ends up runner up or something. That’s why the judges had to stomach feed you all girls so at least one could win.

  3. grandma to many May 2, 2013 at 3:01 am -  Reply

    Àmber has great potential but remember this is the show that made Fantasia a winner ? And Jennifer Hudson a loser ! Good luck with your career Amber Idol is just a springboard most winners never make it to the top level

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Featured Video

Jordan's winning moment on The Voice

Jordan Smith became the Season 9 winner of The Voice Dec. 15. Head here for a photo gallery from Jordan's big night.

Latest tweets



RSS From the York Dispatch

  • An error has occurred, which probably means the feed is down. Try again later.
February 2016
« Jan